Professor Andrew Geddis says [I think Fishers core criticism of Binnies approach to the physical evidence is right.
Otago University Law School Dean Mark Henaghan [http://tvnz.co.nz/breakfast-news/jud...-video-5292419 ]
Professor Kevin Dawkins [The Otago University law professor, Kevin Dawkins, told Radio New Zealand last week that he agreed with Robert Fisher’s criticism that Binnie failed to consider circumstantial evidence and the way we in New Zealand approach it.
Professor Dawkins said Binnie’s dismissal of individual pieces of evidence was problematic and “corroborates the Minister of Justice’s conclusion that the finding in the report is not supported by robust reasoning and analysis”.
He also agreed that Binnie incorrectly imposed the burden on the Crown to prove Bain wasn’t innocent, when the onus of proof should have lain with David Bain.